A Civil War Adventure Story
Book Review: Junius and Albert’s Adventures in the Confederacy, by Peter Carlson
Well, I’ve used up the material from all of our 2015 travels, and the garden is still frozen. This seems like a good time for a book review. And no, it’s not about gardening.
This is a very good book with a very dumb name. The title, which seems to reference a teen movie franchise, really trivializes the story.
That said, anyone interested in American history (and especially the Civil War), should find this account both entertaining and fascinating.
It concerns Junius Browne and Albert Richardson, two journalists for the New York Herald Tribune. While trying to reach US Grant’s army in April, 1863, they were captured by Confederate soldiers. They spent 18 months in prison, then escaped and made their way to the Union Army with the help of sympathetic Southerners.
At first Browne and Richardson were treated well, even allowed to stay in hotels and go out to dinner in restaurants, though as they were moved from town to town the local newspapers tended to run editorials calling on the populace to lynch them.
Eventually they arrive at Libby Prison in Richmond, then transferred to Salisbury Prison in North Carolina. Even in prison the two received better treatment than rank and file soldiers. Things got worse for all, however, as the prisons became progressively more overcrowded – to the point where prisoners slept in holes in the ground, without any shelter.
The rapidly growing number of prisoners-of-war combined with food shortages and plain old sadism to create truly horrendous conditions in the Southern prison camps.
Junius Browne volunteered in the prison hospital, where he was known as “Dr. Browne” despite his complete lack of training. Because the prison kept no record of deaths and buried prisoners in mass graves, Browne kept his own list of fatalities among the inmates. He wanted to at least give families of the deceased certain knowledge of what had happened to their loved ones. By the time he escaped, this list had 1,200 names.
Browne and Richardson escaped in December 1864 with the help of one of the prison administrators who happened to be a Union spy. They spent the next month traveling mostly by foot to reach the Union lines near Knoxville in Eastern Tennessee.
This would not have been possible without the help of strangers. In central North Carolina these good Samaritans were slaves. The slaves never betrayed Browne and Richardson and could usually be relied on to feed and hide them, despite the grave risks this involved.
In the mountains of western North Carolina and eastern Tennessee, slaves were few and far between. However, there were plenty of white Union sympathizers, some of whom were organized into a secret society called the Heroes of America.
In this region there was a Civil War within the Civil War. The woods were full of local men, both deserters from the Confederate Army and those who went into hiding to avoid the draft. Hiding in this way was known as “lying out”, and those lying out were known as “outliers”.
The mountains were full of violence between bands of pro-union outliers, the pro-secession Home Guard, and occasional expeditions of regular Confederate troops.
The outliers and their families were the ones who got Browne and Richardson across the rugged, snow-covered mountains. In fact, Browne and Richardson were not entirely unique. Numerous bands of escaped northern prisoners were guided home through these mountains, and local boys who volunteered for the Union Army would sneak back home for family visits before heading back to continue their military service.
This book reads like a novel, and gives a far more intimate portrait of the two reporters than I indicate here. And there are plenty of other characters of note: other journalists (including one who wrote an entirely fabricated account of the battle of Pea Ridge), the publisher Horace Greeley, farmers and insurgents, spies and cutthroats, as well the unfortunate residents of Libby and Salisbury prisons.
Carlson’s book makes a good companion to others, like The Free State of Jones by Victoria Bynum, that indicate the Civil War story is more complicated than is sometimes acknowledged, and that support for secession among white Southerners was less than universal.
This sounds like a good book for my eldest son who will be studying the Civil War for his history A-level next year. He’s really looking forward to going from studying 11 subjects, most of which he’s not especially interested in, to 3 subjects that he loves; history being the main one. There’s even going to be a field trip to the U.S. to visit key sites. Lucky boy.
He should have a fantastic time on that trip. Yes I think this is an excellent book for someone in their teens who loves history.
Thanks. Sounds wonderful. One fun part of history is that the more one reads, the more complicated it gets.
I love Civil War history. I will check this book out!
I think you’ll enjoy it.
So much coverage about the Civil War is repetative. This looks like a refreshing insight into an aspect we seldom hear about…like the book ‘Cold Mountain’ and the PBS series ‘Mercy Street’. Thanks for the tip.
I liked ‘Cold Mountain’ but have been disappointed in ‘Mercy Street’ so far. I just don’t think the writing is very good.
I like history of all kinds and this book sounds really interesting. Thanks!
i grew up with books about the Civil War, all told from the point of view of the losers, and I find it hard to build enthusiasm for any book on the topic, however interesting. Rickii mentioned Cold Mountain. I’m a big reader but that book I found unreadable. It’s winter, I need some pretty pictures of flowers. Please, help!!!
OK, message received!
There is a lot of Civil War history in my family, so this sounds like a very interesting read to me. My grandparents told stories of that war passed down from their grandparents, who were actually involved in the war.
My family came here long after the Civil War, but I still find it fascinating. To me it is like the American Illiad.
What a story! And you’re right. The title doesn’t do the book justice. Without your review, I wouldn’t have given the book a second thought. Now, I’m thinking what a good present it would make for my son-in-law, who is a Civil War buff.
It’s a very fast read, hard to put down, not like some of those weighty Civil War tomes.
Again, thanks for the review.
Even back then journalist were captured and imprisoned. I never was that interested in the Civil War since the North won, but very interested in the Revolutionary war since we fought united. I suppose I should try and learn more though- good review.
Hard to say why I find the Civil War more compelling. To me it seems like the American Iliad. I enjoyed David McCullough’s biography of John Adams.
My husband shares your interest and has been on a Civil War reading binge for the last two + years. By day he pecks away at a computer in a windowless office trying to untangle people’s legal problems; at night, he somehow has the focus to read Foote and all the other guys etc., in snatches, usually while blocking out the roar of a 4-year old and a 2-year old (and often while rocking the baby cradle with his foot, ha). The house is currently littered with books on Chickamauga (he and a buddy are visiting on a weekend trip soon). Thank you for the recommendation! We are about 35 minutes from Pea Ridge.
Your garden is beautiful–I stumbled on your blog about 6 months ago and enjoy it very much. On your recommendation, I have a packet of Mexican sun flower seeds waiting to go.
I’m sure you’ll enjoy the Mexican Sunflowers – they are great butterfly magnets. I think my favorite Civil War book is The Free State of Jones.